The Libertarian Party Needs to Be Pulling From Both Republicans & Democrats

s1ahtVU4There has been a lot of media attention centered on the Libertarian Party the past few months as they become the alternative for the #NeverTrump crowd.  There are prominent Republicans who are looking to sign on with another candidate that is not Donald Trump and many are suggesting that the Libertarian Party is a place for them.  Many have suggested that Austin Petersen is the candidate in the Libertarian Party that has the best chance of luring disaffected conservatives to the Libertarian movement.

Mary Matalin, the newly minted Libertarian, who switched parties a couple months ago, suggests yesterday:

“In these tumultuous times of domestic and global uncertainty, the country would be well served with Austin Petersen on the national ballot along with the two established party candidates. The times call for, and Americans deserve, a full-throated, clear, coherent call for the restoration of those principles our founders divined and their progeny refined. Austin Petersen is a courageous adherent of and best represents Jefferson’s inviolate first principle: Eternal vigilance is the price of liberty,” noted Ms. Matalin on Tuesday.

Erik Erickson had this to say about Petersen:

Austin Petersen would be a fresh start and a lot of Republicans would potentially take a fresh look at Petersen. Couple him with a very strong, credible vice presidential candidate and the Libertarians might finally be the third party America needs for disruptive competition.

These are both valid assessments of the Petersen campaign and the prospect of him pulling voters from the conservative Republican movement.

But here is the problem…

This doesn’t help the growth of the Libertarian Party!

In order for the Libertarian Party to become a mainstream competitive party they need to pull from both the Republicans and Democrats.  Right now there is only one candidate running for the Libertarian’s that can do that.

Gary Johnson has been included in a number of national polls where he is breaking into double digits.  The key element to note in these polls is Johnson has cross over appeal.  He is pulling from both Trump and Clinton equally.  This is key in order for a third party to win the election.


Governor Johnson appears to be the only Libertarian that has this capability.  While Austin Petersen hits home runs on issues and sass, he seems to be only capable of getting the disaffected Republicans.  While that grows the party in the short term, it does not grow it in the long term. In order to win elections at all levels the Libertarian Party needs to steal from all avenues.  The uniqueness about the Libertarian philosophy is it can appeal to both Republicans and to Democrats.

Gary Johnson is the only one consistently saying that he wants to steal Democratic voters this year and the polls are showcasing that.  He has crafted his positions and his message to take the Republicans and the Democrats.  With the addition of Bill Weld to his ticket this becomes even more of a reality.  Two extremely experienced Governors who hold Libertarian positions making the case to the American electorate will change the game.

Categories: Uncategorized

1 reply »

  1. I disagree with the entire concept that we need to fill our party with republicans and democrats. This article assumes that there are only two political schools of thought, republican and democrat, and that all people easily fit into one of those two containers. It assumes that libertarianism merely steals disenfranchised republicans from the republican bucket. This is a stereotype that has plagued our party and that we as libertarians needs to reject. We are not disenfranchised republicans and we should not look to consume disenfranchised democrats or else we will have a party full of Petersens who will fill our ranks with authoritarian neo-conservatives (or the liberal equivalent), making our party no different from the rest.

    We should grow by deconstructing the current social assumptions of what a libertarian is and educating people on what our philosophy really is. In doing so, people who have historically considered themselves republican or democrat will realize the way I did that there is a party out there that better matches one’s personal beliefs. I left the republican party because I could no longer support social stances of neo-cons. When I found the libertarian party and subsequently Gary Johnson, I found a political ideology that I could back 100%. It pains me to think what may happen if begin to pander to those who don’t necessarily believe our philosophy just so that we can gain numbers. Realistically, I see a net-loss in numbers based on people leaving our party because we don’t like the influence of people who aren’t actually libertarian.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s